Throughout the 1980s there were a number of charity singles released including You'll Never Walk Alone (The Crowd) for the Bradford City Stadium Fire, Let It Be (Ferry Aid) for the Herald Of Free Enterprise Disaster At Zeebrugge, Ferry Cross The Mersey (Gerry Marsden, Paul McCartney, Holly Johnson and The Christians) for the victims of the Hillsborough Disaster and Living Doll (Cliff Richard, The Young Ones and Hank Marvin) for Comic Relief. All of these went to number one in the UK Charts and raised much needed money for the various charities but none had the effect or sales of Band Aid's 1984 charity single Do They Know It's Christmas?
Released forty years ago, on 7 December 1984, and in celebration we look back at the recording, release and how it raised awareness and money for Famine in Ethiopia.
A BBC News report by journalist Michael Buerk in October 1984 about the famine crises in Ethiopia inspired Do They Know It's Christmas? The BBC were the first to document the famine who described it as, "... a biblical famine in the 20th century" and "... the closest thing to hell on Earth."
The report showed Claire Bertschinger, a nurse, having to chose which children would receive the limited amount of food available and those who were too sick to save.
The report shocked the UK and prompted the British public to donate to relief agencies like Save The Children. The disaster also affected Bob Geldof, of the Boomtown Rats, who had watched the report with his wife Paula Yates.
At the time Geldof said, "I really couldn't handle it, you know. I think it was that particular clip where it showed you this nurse and she had to chose 300 babies from a total of 10,000, and in effect those 300 were going to be given some sort of liquids that they had in the camp, and the rest of the 10,000, well, they were going to die."
He went on to say, "It was this sort of random decision between life and death that really got me. So it just affected me pretty badly, and I started to think, well I know a hell of a lot of people, I must be able to get something organised."
It all started because of Bob Geldof... The man bellowed and blustered at anyone and everyone he could get his hands on to make this thing work. He shouted at people so that his word could be turned into food for Ethiopia.
A few days after the BBC report, Yates was at the Tyne Tees studios in Newcastle presenting the music show The Tube and one of the groups appearing on the show was Ultravox. The bands frontman Midge Ure was chatting to Yates in the dressing room when she received a call from Geldof who asked to speak to Ure.
During the conversation Geldof said he wanted to do something to help end the suffering in Ethiopia and they agreed to meet for lunch. A few days later they met and the idea to make a charity record was conceived.
Midge Ure recalled the telephone call, "I was up in Newcastle recording The Tube when Bob Geldof called me. I did it because anybody in the music business can exploit their position to help a good cause like this."
The first job was to write and record the song and one of the biggest challenges to overcome was to write and record it in time for Christmas, a matter of just a few weeks away!
Bob Geldof and Midge Ure chose to write an original song rather than record a cover version. The reasoning behind this was to avoid having to pay royalties which would reduce the amount of money raised.
Ure went away and over several days in his home studio composed a Christmas sounding melody on a portable keyboard and drum machine which, when played to Geldof, he remarked that it sounded more like a TV theme.
The next day they joined forces and worked on the song with Geldof playing acoustic guitar and adding lyrics that were based on a song Geldof had written for The Boomtown Rats, with the working title It's My World.
With a tape of Geldof playing guitar, Ure continued working on the backing track back at his home studio adding his own melody as a chorus. A sample of the drums from the 1983 Tears For Fears track The Hurting was used for the intro while both John Taylor and Paul Weller visited to add bass and lead guitar which both Weller and Ure felt did not fit and so was not used on the final recording.
Ure added a guide vocal and the only change he made to Geldof's new lyrics was on the line 'And there won't be snow in Africa this Christmas time.' Originally it was 'There won't be snow in Ethiopia...' but Ethiopia didn't fit due to the amount of syllables and he replaced it with Africa.
The next stage was to gather musicians to work on the project. Geldof called Sting and Simon Le Bon who both agreed to participate. A chance meeting with Gary Kemp in London resulted in both Gary, along with the rest of Spandau Ballet, Martin Kemp, John Keeble and Tony Hadley all agreeing to be involved.
With some of the biggest bands around offering their time it prompted Geldof to comment, "It suddenly hit me. I thought, Christ, we have got the real top boys here, all the big names in pop are suddenly ready and willing to do this. I knew then that we were off, and I just decided to go for all the rest of the faces and started to ring everyone up, asking them to do it."
It wasn't long before the list of people happy to help read like a who's who of the current pop music scene... George Michael, Francis Rossi, Rick Parfitt, Boy George, Paul Weller, Paul Young, Phil Collins, Bono and Sara Dallin, Siobhan Fahey and Keren Woodward of Bananarama.
It was not only the lead singers, as members of the various groups were not going to be left out and these included... Pete Briquette, Simon Crowe and Johnny Fingers (Boomtown Rats), Andy Taylor, John Taylor, Roger Taylor and Nick Rhodes (Duran Duran), Chris Cross (Ultravox) and Dennis Thomas, Robert 'Kool' Bell and James 'J.T' Taylor (Kool & The Gang). All of the artists offered their time free of charge.
Pop band The Thompson Twins were out of the country and unavailable but offered to donate part of the royalties from their single, Lay Your Hands On Me, to the charity.
Everyone knew that this record had to be a success. It went beyond their personal careers and personal views.
Apparently only three people refused to be involved and Geldof declined to mention who they were.
It wasn't just artists that Geldof approached and also contributing to the project were various UK music magazines including Smash Hits, Sounds, Melody Maker and Music Week, who offered advertising space to promote the single, Phonogram Records (Geldof's record label) who would release the single, and PolyGram who would deal with the distribution. Peter Blake, who created the iconic cover for The Beatles album Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band, would design the single's sleeve.
Geldof had approached Trevor Horn to produce the record and he was agreeable, but as an in-demand producer who had achieved three number one singles for Frankie Goes To Hollywood during the year, said he would need six weeks or more. This would mean missing the Christmas market and although he would go on to produce the 12-inch version it was Midge Ure who would gain the producer credit.
Geldof and Ure arrived at the studio around 8am on the morning of Sunday 25 November and the press were already there to record the event. The session was scheduled to start at 10.30am and the press captured the artists as they arrived.
The Daily Mirror were given exclusive access to the studio and one of their first jobs was to capture a group photo, which was taken by staff photographer Brian Aris, and would appear in the next days issue creating publicity for the record.
With everybody assembled Ure played the back tracking and his guide vocal to the artists. The decision was made to record the ending of the song first and with every artists in a large group they sang the final few lines over and over again... 'Feed the world, let them know it's Christmas time again.'
Tony Hadley was then chosen to record his solo section first, not without some apprehension. He later said it was nerve-wracking having all his contemporaries standing around watching him.
One by one each artist laid down there own solo segments as Ure recorded their efforts and kept notes about which sections would be used in the final mix.
Both Simon Le Bon and Sting had recorded a vocal at Ure's house during the time spent working on the backing track. However, Le Bon wanted to re-record his part so as to be part of the moment. Meanwhile Sting added his words again to provide harmony vocals to his earlier recording.
Bono was at first reluctant to sing the line 'Well tonight thank God it's them instead of you' but Geldof managed to persuade him.
Despite having written the song both Geldof and Ure chose not to sing any solo parts although they did join in for the finale.
A the time a comment summed up the feeling about the record and what it was aiming to achieve... "Hopefully if the fans of the people who are here today and have played on the record go out an buy it, then it'll be number one, and for once we'll have a record there that's for a good cause."
Most of the backing track had been completed by Ure before the session but on the day of recording two additional musicians would feature. Phil Collins of Genesis played some excellent drumming on the recording while Duran Duran's John Taylor played bass guitar. Collins waited till most of the vocals had been recorded before laying his parts down. Ure was happy with the first take but Collins asked to do a second take which was used on the record.
The last person to add their vocal to the song was Boy George who was in New York and nearly didn't make it to the session. Geldof had called him the day before insisting he attend. George managed to take the last flight of the day on Concorde and turned up at Sarm West Studios around 6pm and went straight to the recording booth and added his lines to the song.
The planned B-side, Feed The World, used the instrumental track onto which Christmas messages from the artists who had been at the session, and those who were unable to attend, were added. David Bowie, Paul McCartney, Holly Johnson along with Stuart Adamson, Mark Brzezicki, Tony Butler and Bruce Watson, all members of Big Country, who were not able to attend the session recorded messages for inclusion.
Although Annie Lennox's name would appear on the sleeve and a message from her was meant to be included on the B-side it arrived too late to be used.
At the end of the day and after the recording session had finished. Geldof recorded his own statement which become the last message on Feed The World.
His spoken-word piece said, "This record was recorded on the 25th of November 1984. It's now 8am in the morning of the 26th. We've been here 24-hours and I think it's time we went home. So from me, Bob Geldof, and Midge, we'd say, 'Good morning to you all, and a million thanks to everyone on the record. Have a lovely Christmas.'"
While all this additional recording was taking place, Ure started working on mixing the track.
Comments from some of the artists show why they were more than happy to be involved in the project and these are just a few...
"I'm delighted to be here. When Bob rang to ask us to turn up we just dropped everything. It's a great idea and it shows, I hope, that we care. Just buy it, for everyone in Ethiopia." (Simon Le Bon)
"The fact that I did it speaks for itself. It's obvious why I did it." (Boy George)
"People always talk about helping out, but I am very happy that I was physically able to do something to help, over this disturbing problem." (John Moss)
"It's the sort of project that if you're asked to join you immediately say yes. I thought it was right, and I wanted to be involved in it." (Rick Parfitt)
"The reason for my participation in the project should be obvious. I have always tried to help out with worthwhile causes where and when in the past. I was very flattered to have been asked - and I didn't expect such a lively and prestigious turnout." (Phil Collins)
The day after the session Geldof appeared on the BBC Radio One Breakfast Show hosted by Mike Read. During his appearance he promoted the record and stated that every penny raised would go to Famine in Ethiopia. Radio One also played the record every hour, much more than any other A-listed single would receive.
Within a week of the recording of Do They Know It's Christmas?, and before its official release date, it had racked up advance orders of more than 250,000 and within a few days the orders placed by the record shops had reached one million.
To meet this demand PolyGram, who were distributing the single, utilised all five of their pressing plants in Europe.
Do They Know It's Christmas? backed with Feed The World (Catalogue Number FEED 1) was released on 7 December, costing just £1.35, and entered the UK charts at number one the following week. It sold more copies that week than the rest of chart put together, an outstanding achievement.
Trevor Horn produced a 12-inch single which had a running time of just over 6 minutes compared to the 7-inch single which ran to just under 4 minutes.
Actual sales reached over a million in the first week, and by the end of the year the single had shifted more than three million copies.
Wham's festive release, Last Christmas, was kept off the top spot by Do They Know It's Christmas? and they donated their royalties to the charity.
In the USA it was released on 10 December and sold almost two million within the first two weeks. However, due to differences in how the charts were compiled, it failed to reach number one and peaked at #13 on the Billboard Hot 100.
The record did reach number one in more than ten countries worldwide including, Australia, Norway, Netherlands, Austria, Canada, Denmark and Ireland.
Despite the support and time given for free from everyone involved there was one issue that would infuriate Geldof following the release of the single. The British Government refused to waive the VAT charged on the sales of the single! It was only when he publicly stood up to Margaret Thatcher, Prime Minister at the time, that the Government did a U-Turn and donated an amount to the charity, equal to what had been collected in tax.
Within a year, and far exceeding Geldof's expectations, the single raised more than £8 million.
Re-released a year later, in November 1985, it reached #3 in a newly remixed version by Trevor Horn. It had an updated B-side, One Year On (Feed The World), which began and ended with a telephone message from Geldof and throughout the track, Ure talks about what had been bought with the money raised so far.
By 1989 worldwide sales were over 11 million and in the UK alone it had sold almost 4 million by 2017.
Most singles released around this time had an official video produced. However, due to time restrictions, a video was made using just the footage from the recording session. Normally a video wouldn't be shown on BBCs flagship music show, Top Of The Pops, until it had charted, meaning it could not be shown on the 29 November episode. Geldof contacted Michael Grade, BBC 1 Controller, and persuaded him to run every programme due to be broadcast before that weeks TOTP to start five minutes earlier. This allowed the video to be broadcast before Top Of The Pops started.
The UK music press had mixed feelings about the song. NME wrote, "Millions of dead stars write and perform rotten record for the right reasons." Unfair and to be honest, typical of NME. Meanwhile Sounds felt the song was, "... far from brilliant but you can have fun playing Spot the Star."
They all seemed to be missing the point of the record. Melody Maker seemed to follow the familiar pattern when they reviewed the single saying, "Inevitable, after such massive publicity, the record itself is something of an anti-climax, even though Geldof's sense of universal melodrama is perfectly suited to this kind of epic musical manifesto. Midge Ure's large-screen production and the emotional vocal deliveries of the various celebrities matches the demonstrative sweep of Geldof's lyric, which veers occasionally toward an uncomfortably generalised sentimentality which threatens to turn righteous pleading into pompous indignation." They ended the review with, "On the other hand, I'm sure it's impossible to write flippantly about something as fundamentally dreadful as the Ethiopia famine."
There was also criticism from other quarters. Various sources criticised it's colonial western-centric viewpoint, condescending stereotypical descriptions of Africa and one publication even deemed the lyrics as racist and demeaning towards Ethiopians.
Even Bono was hit with criticism for his line, 'Well tonight thank God it's them instead of you.'
Over the years both Geldof and Ure have responded to the criticism. In his autobiography Ure wrote. "It is a song that has nothing to do with music. It was all about generating money. The song didn't matter, the song was secondary, almost irrelevant." Geldof, speaking in 2024, said, "This little pop song has kept hundreds of thousands if not millions of people alive." Responding to the criticism of the lyrics he went on to say, "The alleged 'colonial tropes' of the lyrics were in fact 'empirical facts', and that hunger remains endemic in Ethiopia, water is scarce and rain is increasingly unreliable due to climate change."
Despite the unfair criticism Do They Know It's Christmas? was an important record which achieved much more than anyone involved could ever have imagined. It helped save millions of lives and bought worldwide attention to what was happening in Ethiopia.
The following year Live Aid would raise even more money but that is a story for another day and one which I might cover in a future blog.